Luffy's Mom - Page 4 - Arlong Park Forums

Insider2000 · September 28th, 2008, 02:46 PM

Okay. I think it is obvious that a lot of us are predicting that Hancock is Luffy's mother. Of course, none of know if this is true.

Here's the thing. I feel that Hancock bears a facial resemblance to Luffy. Luffy looks more like her than his own father.

But then comes several issues.
1. How can someone who seems so bitter and cold be chosen as Luffy's mother?

Dragon doesn't seem like the nicest person in the world, but who knows. Love can exist between two people on opposing beliefs. Look at Luffy and Garp.

2. Why doesn't Hancock seem to care that Ace is being executed?

Let's not forget that Ace has a different last name. If Hancock is Luffy's mother, she might not know or care that Ace is Luffy's step brother (if Dragon left groin spawns in different places, which we assume with Ace's last name).

3. How could Dragon ever possibly get the heart of Hancock?

This is something I really wonder. Dragon must either be really sly or really romantic for Hancock to ever fall in love with Dragon. Perhaps Dragon is devoid of sexual thoughts, which amazes Hancock.

Dragon must have something truly amazing about him to gain her heart.

This discussion does NOT say that Hancock IS Luffy's mother. This discusses the possibility of her being his mother. None of us are Oda. This is entirely theory based. Okay? Okay.

Zik · September 28th, 2008, 03:38 PM

Quote:

I feel that Hancock bears a facial resemblance to Luffy.

No No No No No No No No No No All of Oda's characters can have some type facial resemblance to another. I've said it before but Garp and Dragon don't look alike and those two don't look like Luffy.

Sesshy · September 28th, 2008, 03:58 PM

I honestly believe Luffy's mother is somebody like Makino if it isn't her.

Either that or she was a monkey before entering the monkey family. That would explain a lot about Luffy either way you took it (Incest or bestiality.)

mr.zero · September 28th, 2008, 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Insider2000

Okay. I think it is obvious that a lot of us are predicting that Hancock is Luffy's mother. Of course, none of know if this is true.

THANK YOU! idk why so many people are like OMG HANCOCK IS HIS MOTHER!!!!!! without any proof at all. seriously, come on. She's more likely to be lola's mother. Luffy's mom is probably not the last yonkou, becuase we've seen pictures of all the yonkou's faces and none of them look female. but hey. i could be wrong. idk. she probably won't be revealed for a long time.

Insider2000 · September 28th, 2008, 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zik

No No No No No No No No No No All of Oda's characters can have some type facial resemblance to another. I've said it before but Garp and Dragon don't look alike and those two don't look like Luffy.

Look at Robin. Robin looks EXACTLY like her mother, except for the hair. During the time Olivia was reveal, we were to assume that she was OBVIOUSLY Robin's mother.

When Dragon was revealed, he was meant to be a character of complete mystery. So Oda isn't going to make him look exactly like Luffy, or else we'd figure out their connection ourselves.

Now, AGAIN. I'm not saying Hancock IS Luffy's mother. We don't know that. I just believe that the theory has merit. I'm not going to shove it down people's throats as 'truth'.

And concerning Garp's relation to Dragon or Hancock. We don't know who is the mother of that relationship is.

EDIT: My apologies for not seeing this thread earlier.

estarapapax · September 30th, 2008, 09:57 AM

Luffy's grandpa serves the World Government and his father is a revolutionary. Both are in the extreme ends. If Luffy's mother will really play an important role, then I guess she should be in between, say a peace advocate or something.

Aceburner · September 30th, 2008, 12:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Insider2000

2. Why doesn't Hancock seem to care that Ace is being executed?

Let's not forget that Ace has a different last name. If Hancock is Luffy's mother, she might not know or care that Ace is Luffy's step brother (if Dragon left groin spawns in different places, which we assume with Ace's last name).

The main problem I have with this point is the fact that Luffy is a Monkey D., just like Dragon. This would imply that last names in general come from the father in at least Dragon's relationships. If this were the case, then assuming that they only share one parent if any, Ace's other genes would come from a different father, not mother.

Not to say that anyone's wrong or right. I'm not Oda, after all. Besides, there are plenty of other possibilities. The different mother may have decided to give him her maiden name, or he may have had a falling out and changed it himself.

Personally, I'm betting that they're either full brothers or they have a different father. That's just my opinion, though.

Roku Ou Gan · September 30th, 2008, 09:48 PM

Gonna add some other random stuff
-Maybe she cares about Ace but that's the reason why she's NOT going to help them fight Whitebeard
-Maybe she's not Luffy's but Ace's mom!
-If she's Luffy's mom, that means Luffy's got 2 weird looking aunts. Weird huh
-If she's Ace's mom...^ ^ ^ ^ ^

yeah. I want her to be Luffy's mom though, just so Sanji could be like "wow Luffy your mom's hot"

crazymonkey · October 3rd, 2008, 03:50 PM

Luffy's mom was killed by WG , that's why Dragon fight against WG.

regasatanum · October 4th, 2008, 02:34 AM

^ok, If theres any relation between luffy and boa, she wil be luffy's stepmother

~~Tenryuken~~ · October 4th, 2008, 03:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Insider2000

Let's not forget that Ace has a different last name. If Hancock is Luffy's mother, she might not know or care that Ace is Luffy's step brother (if Dragon left groin spawns in different places, which we assume with Ace's last name).

Garp never said that Ace is his grandchild. when he was talking about Dragon he said that he was only Luffy's dad not Ace's. If Luffy got his last name from his father, why wouldn't Ace? Boa Hancock is their mom and maybe long ago when she wasn't the emperess but just a Kuja pirate on the island's boat with others female's, she encountered a man during a fight or something else(I don't think they are allow to go out and seduce men). The man she encountered won the fight and thus was allowed her "flower". That man's name is Portgas D Shanks. Maybe because Shanks is a D she got a boy and wasn't allow to raise him.

Couple years later she was defeated again, this time the man was Monkey D Dragon and the whole story repeated itself.

Ushae · October 4th, 2008, 08:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Meh*

My theory has always been that Luffy's mom got a leeetle to close to uncovering the WG's secrets, so they had her killed, and that this is part of what drove Dragon to seek their annihilation.

That's a decent theory..

amon · October 4th, 2008, 10:24 AM

luffy' s mom and dad was piratates of the crew of roger, and the mom of luffy is the keeper of the one piece on raftel

Naginata · October 4th, 2008, 11:50 AM

I am going with the Boa Hancock being Luffy's mother. Them looking alike might not be proof, but there a some other things that point to it (at least for me)

He has seen something like what is on Boa's back. Not proof, but suspicious. If she and Dragon and a one night stand or something, and she thought the child would be female as all other children born to them are (possible a haki technique that kills or keeps the male baby makers away and attacks the female? and she forgot to use it?) If this did happen then it could take a while to find Dragon again and dump Luffy on him, possible long enough for him to see her back enough to vaguely remember it.

Also, Luffy did not turn into stone. Again, not proof, since the curse might not be real. But if it is, then Luffy being of her flesh and blood could give him some immunity to it.

No proof, but it is the most we have to go on. Right now, until it is either proven or disproved, Boa Hancock is the best bet.

(oh, and about Ace, I would say his mother died, which caused Dragon to have the fling with Boa)

Buuhan1 · October 4th, 2008, 05:50 PM

I like how the one piece community goes on "gonna join!" when a new character is introduced, especially if she's female, and goes "luffy's mom!" when an older female is introduced. Everyone was/is saying Caimie and Marguerite are gonna join, and now people are saying Boa is luffy's mom

ramza85 · October 4th, 2008, 08:26 PM

I firmly believe she is Luffy's mom..
100% confidence in it till proven otherwise.. Not due to the above said arguments given by many others.. But following my instinct..
So how many are with me? Those sitting on the fence thinking it might be plausible please make your choice..
Anyway it would make a good plot for the Ace execution..

iSheep · October 5th, 2008, 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramza85

100% confidence in it till proven otherwise..

Well, Luffy saw her naked in the bath. Would be a little creepy if he saw his mother naked, don't you think?

~~Tenryuken~~ · October 5th, 2008, 03:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iSheep

Well, Luffy saw her naked in the bath. Would be a little creepy if he saw his mother naked, don't you think?

Not if he don't know her but just barely remember what ever is on her back.

iSheep · October 5th, 2008, 05:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenryuken

Not if he don't know her but just barely remember what ever is on her back.

It doesn't mean that Luffy or Hancock are weird (ok, they are, but not that kind of weird), but just think about the scene itself. The son crushes in the bath of his mother (It isn't important that he doesn't know her (If she really is his mother)) and see her naked. You need to view it from the readers view and from odas view. Would he really put something like that in a shonen manga that is in the first place designed for kids?
Of course, this is just my opinion

~~Tenryuken~~ · October 5th, 2008, 06:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iSheep

It doesn't mean that Luffy or Hancock are weird (ok, they are, but not that kind of weird), but just think about the scene itself. The son crushes in the bath of his mother (It isn't important that he doesn't know her (If she really is his mother)) and see her naked. You need to view it from the readers view and from odas view. Would he really put something like that in a shonen manga that is in the first place designed for kids?
Of course, this is just my opinion

"Air Gear" is also a shonen manga and that kind of stuff can be fonud in Air Gear. Also Luffy got an "handjob" so I don't think it's weird.