Was Doc Q the only BB crewmate who wasn't nominated?
He'd be my second choice (Kohza third after reading that intro comic.. or Norland), but I gotta go with Gan Fall. He's doesn't have any devil fruit, super strength, nor strange powers; just a regular yet badass old man making due with what he has. What he has being dials and lances and horse-birds.
On top of that, he's probably the genuinely nicest of all the geezers. A real stand-up guy.
Oh yeah, AND HE'S THE OTHER GOD.