One Piece Mafia: Part II

[Shuhan]

Well that is clearly not completely true for i asked to investigate bogart and reminded you twice because the night went on for longer then it should have.

[Ami-Louise]

Fine.... *Sigh*I totally call that unfair though...

[Shuhan]

Also, as a note...Xasjjx is back to fill the last spot that has been left vacant...

He has no real knowledge of behind the scenes other than the speculation between the other graveyard mates.

He has a completely different role as well...be nice to him...or not...

I really could care less...

[Kitsune Inferno]

But... I wanted to be the fifteenth housemate. :(

[xasjjx]

I'd also like to say that they're using a different QT now so I can't talk to them and that I can't talk anything about I read in the graveyard.

--- Update From New Post Merge ---

say anything*

[Shuhan]

I'd also like to say that they're using a different QT now so I can't talk to them and that I can't talk anything about I read in the graveyard.

--- Update From New Post Merge ---

say anything*

....you looked back....

[Wooden_Giraffe]

Maybe you should mod kill him and give me both roles, as well as two votes and two lives.

[xasjjx]

Of couse I did, I got bored waiting for you to start the day~

Huschel, would you have lynched Silent if you were present during the past two days?

--- Update From New Post Merge ---

Harvy you're here now! Mind sharing why you've been absent for the majority of the game?

[Shuhan]

Maybe you should mod kill him and give me both roles, as well as two votes and two lives.

How bout we reenact burning man...cept its burning Giraffe...

[Wooden_Giraffe]

I don't support that idea at all.

Also, HAVARDY!!! I'm sure you're super busy or something and have a bit to catch up on but I would really like to hear from you.

[Bogart]

You probably forgot to bold it, Ami.

There's so much about this game that leaves me speechless. However I will say this, Shuhan: I will get my satisfaction from this game out of you. One way or another.

[Huschel]

Huschel, would you have lynched Silent if you were present during the past two days?

I would have, yes. Unfortunately the last two days were pretty short and I was busy. Which hasn't exactly changed but I'll try to give some input today.

And I suppose I should just ignore the fact that you are back? I don't really get it but apparently it's not at all ability-related, right?

Ami-Louise, it seems like you have been roleblocked. Therefore you didn't get a report. Or at least that's what Occam's Razor is telling me.

--- Update From New Post Merge ---

About Harvady: I'm not sure what to do think about him. I pretty much ignored him even though he was lurking because thanks to him a mafia got lynched on the first day. But we're way too close to the end of the game to tolerate lurking any longer. So yeah, speak up, please.

[Shuhan]

Shuhan: I will get my satisfaction from this game out of you. One way or another.

[Silent K]

You all got some nerve, using this farce of a game to attack me.
Laugh at me all you like; I'll slaughter you.

[Bogart]

A watcher with no given reports, ever. Dead.

A tracker with no given reports, ever. No real posts, either. Dead.

A nexus who didn't speak for the entire game- not that I can hold it against him. Dead.

A player who didn't speak for almost the entire game- who will almost certainly be held accountable. *

A suicide bomber who was probably just waiting to kill someone, explaining why his posts weren't serious. Dead...and back. And we're supposed to believe he could be either Mafia or Town? Yeah, nah.

A follower who died as he lived- I had to look up his power because I forgot it. Dead.

A player who's posted off-topic more times than on. *

A naughty lost child. Dead.

A very devoted (and very unlucky) baby-sitter. Dead.

A cop who claimed day two and still lives: the only explanation why being that he better serves the Mafia that way.

A 'clear' who acts- and probably kills- on instinct rather than...reading.

A Mafia player who truthfully got what he deserved. Dead. **

A Mafia player who can't be killed or lynched. **

** Definitely Mafia.
* Probably Mafia.

Vote Lynch: Huschel

[Harvady Alumnus]

If I didn't want anyone to call me out, I would've went invisible. The fact that it took this long is just surpising. D3 doesn't really matter, as it ended halfway through with Silent's lynch.

I dropped off the grid in hopes that the mafia wouldn't kill me. It seems to have worked, but I more or less had the wind taken out of my sails at the end of D1. So I opted for the opposite, to spite the lack of lurker punishment. BOO! Boo, I say! BOO! Where is my sweet D1 victory?! Where is my endless epic, edifying and eternal, endowing exemplary esteem?! BOO! Changing the rules out from under me?! BOO! Why should I bother with a new plan when I can be undermined by the moderator at any time?! BOO!
That's not to say I haven't been following. At this point, there's so much to say, but only a few things to do. So I might as well get a train or two going.

MASSCLAIM: I'm the Doctor. Nectar N1, Ami-Louise N2 & N3.

There are seven of us left, the fact that it should have been six is more than telling enough. Ami claimed early, much to town's suffering, and Wooden has more or less made his piece known. (Get it? It's a pun.)

Vote Lynch: Huschel

His posts let on to the idea that he is privy to things that we're not. He's also one of the "garbage" posters from D1. Considering his company: Mastello and Silent, it's not a stretch to say he's the third if not last.

Except that it's been made obvious that he isn't the last by the that statement he made saying that we're 'way too close'. Had there only been two mafia, we could have sustained another mislynch. With three mafia we're at lylo. Again, there should've only been six of us today, making the game effectively over. Xas was added to prolong the game. Meaning he's not mafia, and that there are three left.

It's not Xas, Wooden claimed and was cleared by the only cop, Ami. It's not me. We already know that Silent's mafia. If there are only two left then I prefer Huschel to Bogart. If there are three, then it's both.

[Bogart]

Oh, hey. It's the doctor. Never mind Ami was completely useless and more than likely never targeted based on the constant stream of death. Never mind he didn't post until someone saw in the Members Viewing list. Never mind that he's acting on implied information even more so than Huschel, who probably couldn't if he tried. As logical as your Mafia-count = LyLo hypothesis is, based on Shuhan completely undermining the game for a, what, second time? Third time? It's still not a given except to those who are Mafia, and most likely had their win taken from them. My condolences to you. You had to come out with something after all this.

No, it's the fact that I've just been counter-claimed that did it. Claiming Doctor: Harvady N1, Nectar N2, Wooden N3.

Unvote
Vote Lynch: Harvady Alumnus

[Whitebeard.]

hey guys^^
im so sorry for posting here and off topic but id like to ask something..
why cant i make a thread? i cant make anywhere and ive been registered its been 2 months already

[Wooden_Giraffe]

Considering last time Shuhan hosted a game people severely critisized his putting 4 mafia in a 15 player game I find it very hard to believe that he would do it again. Therefore, I'm pretty confident that there are only 2 remaining(Silent and Huschel/Harvy/Bogart). This brings me back to Day 1, when Harvy requested a speed lynch right away when Shuhan had made it clear that those without both a vote and 5 posts would be mod-killed. So had Shuhan not negated his own rule there would have been quite a few deaths that day, while also Harvy getting credit for lynching Mastello, basically making Mastello a sacrifice for 4 or 5 deaths plus some town credit. So as of now my vote will be for him, but I'd still like to hear more, specifically from Huschel about his own thoughts on who the other mafia member is.

--- Update From New Post Merge ---

hey guys^^
im so sorry for posting here and off topic but id like to ask something..
why cant i make a thread? i cant make anywhere and ive been registered its been 2 months already

Try pm'ing a Mod, they're the ones with the colored names. If fact I have the perfect person for you to pm. this Guy

[Harvady Alumnus]

Here's the deal:

At the start of today we would have had six players.

Harvady Alumnus
Bogart
Wooden Giraffe
Silent Klabautermann
Huschel
Ami-Louise

If we only had two mafia left, then the ratio would be 4:2 in favor of town. The game would go on as usual in a Mylo scenario.

However, what if there were three? The ratio would be 3:3, effectively meaning that mafia wins. The game would be over.

Adding xasjjx to the mix:

Harvady Alumnus
Bogart
Wooden Giraffe
Silent Klabautermann
Huschel
Ami-Louise
xasjjx

We have seven. Now, the question is, what is xasjjx's alignment? Is he mafia? If so, then the total number has risen to three. 4:3 in favor of town. Making the game a lylo scenario. Why would the moderator add a mafia member? Were they losing? Did the game need to be shortened? Did he not prove that that wasn't the case with SomebodyUDon'tKnow? If he could afford to randomly kill townies, was adding someone necessary? We lost four townies in two nights.

__________________________________________

I digress. Here's all you need to know.

If we have two mafia, xas's inclusion as town would make the ratio 5:2 in favor of town. Why further the town's advantage? Not logical.
If we have two mafia, xas's inclusion as mafia would make the ratio 4:3 in favor of town. Why force the game into Lylo? Not logical.
If we have three mafia, xas's inclusion as town would make the ratio 4:3 in favor of town. This stops the game from ending. Without his inclusion, the game would be over.
If we have three mafia, xas's inclusion as mafia would make the ratio 3:4 in favor of mafia. This would be impossible, as the game would have ended regardless of his inclusion. Not logical.

The only sensible reason to include xas is to keep the game going. Whether or not he's town or third party just means that he's not mafia.

Therefore, there are three mafia. xasjjx is not mafia.