Blackbeard vs Magellan

[Gokuyuske]

Blackbeard realy does crap in the tournament all around, eh ?

Yeah the forum hates him for some reason. He's a great villain though. Everything he does in Jaya gives me chills.

[Lazy Ass Justice]

He was great in his first appearance.
And then: I`m a dick!

[Katzztar]

He was great in his first appearance.
And then: I`m a dick!

heh, you've summed it up pretty well. If he still acted as he did in Jaya/ Mocktown, I'd like him better. Heck when he went after Luffy in his Raft boat he was still cool to me, everything afterward though... nope not my fave opponent of Luffy's.
Magellen does, he's a more complex in that while he (was) head of a very brutal prision, he still had standards and didn't let his subodinates cross the line, as shown when he imprisioned Shilew for exsessive cruelty

[Law of the sea]

Blackbeard realy does crap in the tournament all around, eh ?

Most of the people voting against him like him better than magellan but its better to vote him out now before he goes against the character that people want to win the tournament.

[Hiroy]

Blackbeard is a hatable villian. He does his job well. Infact, the votes agaist him would be for him.

[Kubihige]

Blackbeard is tied with Crocodile for best villain laugh of all time. Despite still having not shown too much, he's already got best villain ever pretty much wrapped up :3

[andre]

Lolwut?

Wait, this just made me realize... Are there any fat characters who are GOOD in One Piece? D:

Tons of them!!! Tom, Lucky Roo, Jinbei, Moriah, Wadatsumi, Dadan, Brogy and Brownbeard!!

[Counterdose]

I wouldn’t vote against Blackbeard for being despicable; I’m a general fan of the nasties - cowardly tactics included.
It’s just that he’s only so interesting.

I LOVED Magellan’s role in the story, capabilities and appearance. Amazing character.

[Jabra]

Tons of them!!! Tom, Lucky Roo, Jinbei, Moriah, Wadatsumi, Dadan, Brogy and Brownbeard!!

To be fair, Tom and Jinbe don't really count. They were born with their figure (see chibi Jinbe from the SBS), and I doubt they can change it since they are simply fishman.

BB, however....

Spoiler:

That scene was super awesome tho.

[Nolus]

I didn't vote against Blackbeard.

I voted for Magellan. Because of campaigns.

[The Daz]

This is an impossible one for me.
On one hand there's Blackbeard, who shits all over the perceptions of what a shonen endboss should be like.

On the other, theres Magellan, one of the best characters hands down of the last few years. A complete package of awesome design, awesome power, awesome personality, and awesome scenes.

So I wont vote, but I'm happy with the results.

[Venomous Warden]

I see blackbeard is gaining a bit of momentum, so its time to pull out the venom demon

Spoiler:

Vote for the man that made impel down worth the trip

Vote Magellan

[andre]

To be fair, Tom and Jinbe don't really count. They were born with their figure (see chibi Jinbe from the SBS), and I doubt they can change it since they are simply fishman.

BB, however....

Spoiler:

http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__...blackbeard.jpg

That scene was super awesome tho.

Blackbeard's child picture says the same thing about him. And I don't think eating a lot in the one piece universe is what makes one fat. Look at the amount of meat Luffy eats. Blackbeard's fatness is his fate, as is the fatness of Jinbe and Tom. (also, Jinbe was smaller when he was in the military.)

[Jabra]

Blackbeard's child picture says the same thing about him. And I don't think eating a lot in the one piece universe is what makes one fat. Look at the amount of meat Luffy eats. Blackbeard's fatness is his fate, as is the fatness of Jinbe and Tom. (also, Jinbe was smaller when he was in the military.)

I think I laughed more at this than I should. The perfect excuse.

[Venomous Warden]

Ah the sweet taste of victory, although its a little bitter sweet since BlackBeard is also one of my favorite characters that i had previously campaigned for so it kinda sucked having to go against him. He put up a good fight though, and im grateful to everyone who supported magellan in this round.

[Juvar]

This is YOUR victory, VW. Yours and yours alone. 'grats!

[Kitsune Inferno]

And Magellan stinks his way into Round 2, everybody.