+ Reply to Thread
Page 282 of 282 FirstFirst ... 182 232 272 280 281 282
Results 5,621 to 5,633 of 5633

Thread: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

  1. #5621

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Mandorle21 View Post
    Am i wrong or the part with Gums wasn't drawn that good? At least not up to Murata's standards? I mean, definitely above manga average, but it still felt a bit off for some reason.
    He looks very.. simple.
    Same as Murata drawn Black Sperm and Fuhrer Ugly.

    I mean those are Dragon level monsters along with Gums but lack of that much of a detail makes them a bit less impressive. Some of lesser monsters looked to be drawn much better/ looking more scary so top of MA looks less intimidating because Murata went for their looks staying closer to original without adding much of his "sauce".

  2. #5622

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    elder centipede was drawn nice though

  3. #5623
    Your long-lost brother Jabra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    (ಥ ͜ʖ ಥ)

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Mandorle21 View Post
    Am i wrong or the part with Gums wasn't drawn that good? At least not up to Murata's standards? I mean, definitely above manga average, but it still felt a bit off for some reason.
    Considering that this is what Murata had to work with:

    Spoiler:



    his Gums is a work of art.

    In general everything looks amazing, every freaking page. And when not then only because he obviously wanted to preserve the vibe of the original (Black Sperm, Homeless Emperor's god looking like a doodle).


  4. #5624

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    I do not mind Murata using the original art, except for Fuhrer Ugly. There are many monsters in the association who don't exactly fit the definition of "beautiful" and that Mask doesn't seem to have problems with. In order to make him a credible threat, Murata should have given him some ugliness-upgrade.

  5. #5625
    Discovered Stowaway juiceduphody3315's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    New Orleans

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Evil water gave me flashbacks of Ocarina of Time, that water temple boss. That was the worst temple lol.

  6. #5626
    Your long-lost brother Jabra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    (ಥ ͜ʖ ಥ)

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Desperado View Post
    I do not mind Murata using the original art, except for Fuhrer Ugly. There are many monsters in the association who don't exactly fit the definition of "beautiful" and that Mask doesn't seem to have problems with. In order to make him a credible threat, Murata should have given him some ugliness-upgrade.
    Fuhrer Ugly not being "monster level nasty" underlines his theme. He's just an unpleasant looking human.

    If you add anything to that, like a super nasty habit (eating his own snot or something) or an illness (pustules popping randomly) you would ruin his origin. He's just an ugly human, and the way people treated him turned him even uglier.

    At least I interpret it as Sweet Mask being overwhelmed by the extreme ugliness of his heart, not only his unpleasant look.

    And while we are at it, the heart art in the chapter was also amazing....

    Spoiler:



  7. #5627

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Jabra View Post
    Fuhrer Ugly not being "monster level nasty" underlines his theme. He's just an unpleasant looking human. If you add anything to that, like a super nasty habit (eating his own snot or something) or an illness (pustules popping randomly) you would ruin his origin. He's just an ugly human, and the way people treated him turned him even uglier. At least I interpret it as Sweet Mask being overwhelmed by the extreme ugliness of his heart, not only his unpleasant look. And while we are at it, the heart art in the chapter was also amazing....
    The problem is that the things that make a human ugly are pretty much the same things that make a monster ugly. Thus giving Fuhrer Ugly a unique, like, inheritly human kind of ugliness that cannot be found in other monsters may be an impossible task and the only way to set himself off would be to be overwhelmingly ugly. Of course you could go the comedy route for example by making his ugliness petty/an informed attribute that only counts in Sweet Masks value system, but as far as I can tell One/Murata play this straight here. And as far as I can tell, his evilness is the consequence of his ugliness, not vice versa.

  8. #5628

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Jabra View Post
    Considering that this is what Murata had to work with:




    his Gums is a work of art.

    In general everything looks amazing, every freaking page. And when not then only because he obviously wanted to preserve the vibe of the original (Black Sperm, Homeless Emperor's god looking like a doodle).
    Well, i wasn't talking about Gums himself, but all the panels of the whole fight between Gums and Pig God, it's not the character design, it's the art itself that seemed not the best to me.

  9. #5629
    Your long-lost brother Jabra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    (ಥ ͜ʖ ಥ)

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Mandorle21 View Post
    Well, i wasn't talking about Gums himself, but all the panels of the whole fight between Gums and Pig God, it's not the character design, it's the art itself that seemed not the best to me.
    Hm, I guess one can't argue about taste.

    But I honestly can't comprehend it. Especially this page here is so amazing:

    https://mangadex.org/chapter/685436/9

    Super wasteful 3 huge panels and I still know exactly what's going on, just because of Gum's saliva indicating motion and impact so well. Simply brilliant.

    Maybe this means little to others, but I'm someone who *usually* has a hard time following a fight choreography. Sometimes even in high-quality works like One Piece.


  10. #5630
    Saemon Havarian Razh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Croatia

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    It's not just you, Oda has better and worse moments. Just compare the clear cut, move by move Smoker vs Vergo compared to... anything else since, basically.
    Quote Originally Posted by Outerspec View Post
    Trying to understand Bleach is like trying to drink a bottle of bleach.

    It makes no sense and you'll be dead before you're finished.

  11. #5631

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Razh View Post
    It's not just you, Oda has better and worse moments. Just compare the clear cut, move by move Smoker vs Vergo compared to... anything else since, basically.
    Oi Oi.. Katakuris big fight with Luffy was even better. Not much taking into consideration how many chapters we got since Smoker vs Vergo. I hope that Wano will deliver in its last parts in terms of fights.. Hunger for big 1 vs 1 is strong since Enies Lobby.

  12. #5632

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    There hasn't been better fight than Vergo vs Law in terms of visual narrative of movement...

    I enjoy soooo much Murata's art. Nothing to say there


  13. #5633

    Default Re: Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)

    Quote Originally Posted by Ukimix View Post
    There hasn't been better fight than Vergo vs Law in terms of visual narrative of movement...

    I enjoy soooo much Murata's art. Nothing to say there
    I beg to differ. Katakuri vs Luffy was first one that was clearly better for me in that regard.

    As for Muratas artwork, I would like to see his take on One Piece fight - I think it would be quite a sight to see if we got Gear 4th Luffy vs anyone done by Murata.

    Guy is one of best artists when it comes to drawing fights.. Only more impressive than Onepunch Man movement-wise Manga that I seen was Blade of the Immortal.

+ Reply to Thread

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

     

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts